10 N Collective

Early-stage LCA worldwide: 10N’s custom software

24

studios worldwide

5

months from scoping to a tool ready to use

3

indicators side by side

How can architects get a reliable carbon assessment from the concept stage without holding back their creativity? And how can an LCA tool be adapted to your own framework when you work outside RE2020 or with your own data? That is what the custom version of emersus Concept built for 10N, the architecture collective of the Egis group, demonstrates. 10N keeps control of the emission factors, and every architect remains free to change their components and instantly see the effect on carbon.

The goal: decide early, with reliable figures

10N brings together around 1,600 creatives across 24 studios on five continents, around a London headquarters (10N Collective). Its members include Weston Williamson + Partners, known for its infrastructure, transport and social housing projects, and 10 Design, which specialises in commercial and hospitality buildings. The stadium architecture practice FIA based in Spain and dhk in South Africa are more recent additions.

A significant share of a building’s carbon footprint is decided at concept stage: form factor, geometry, choice of façade and structure, and so on. Once these choices are locked in, there is less room for manoeuvre. 10N therefore wanted to give its architects a reliable tool from the very first sketches, following an internationally recognised methodology rather than RE2020, which is specific to France.

A detailed building LCA, carried out at the end of the design process, precisely measures the impact of a project that has already been fixed: it records rather than guides. An early-stage LCA works the other way round. With little data or quantities available, it needs to provide an order of magnitude that is reliable enough to compare options and inform decisions while they are still open. It also lets the designer quantify the potential impact of bolder low-carbon options and strategies for clients: removing basement car parks, switching to a timber structure, proposing an innovative bio-based insulation.

For a collective spread across several continents, the challenge is to fix the boundaries of the assessment so that all speak with one voice and that comparable data is recorded across the studios. A unified framework with clear scope and boundary delimitations is key, while providing a simple and user-friendly tool, designed for architects rather than LCA specialists.

A custom LCA software from emersus Concept

To meet this need, 10N uses a custom version of emersus Concept, our early-stage carbon estimation tool. It strikes a balance between two often conflicting needs: allowing 10N’s carbon team to configure the tool’s assumptions and datasets in detail, then giving architects a simple interface to develop their analyses from, without necessarily getting into the technical details of an LCA.

This balance relies on the concept of the ‘macro-component’. A macro-component is a ready-to-use building assembly, for example a façade build-up with its frame, insulation and cladding. It is described by a functional unit, such as one square metre of wall, and carries a carbon value per unit. Rather than detailing each material of the system, the architects think in terms of building systems, just as they do at concept stage. No more trawling through EPD databases with factors that are hard for non-specialists to check.

Controlled data: The macro-components and their corresponding emission factors are pre-defined by 10N’s carbon team, drawing on various international databases and in-house project experience. By default, international average emission factors are provided and their source clearly labelled, but each studio can still find in its library macro-components specific to its project typologies or region. In addition, the LCA scope includes the often-missed and neglected building services. Even though exact figures are hard to infer at early stage, benchmark figures based on the main design choices (heat pumps, air conditioning or not, etc.) are used so as not to underestimate their contribution to the total carbon footprint. For consistency, all projects rely on the same calculation principles: results are comparable from one project to the next, making them reliable and defendable in front of clients.

A quantity estimation tool that leaves architects free to design: The parameters filled in by the designer, whether the building’s geometry or its type, generate an initial set of quantities for each macro-component: façade area, concrete volumes, and so on. Within this framework, the architect stays in control as they can tweak the suggested quantities for each building component to match the project as closely as possible. Every time the user picks a new macro-component that matches their intent, swaps it, or tweaks a quantity, the assessment is recalculated instantly. The tool doesn’t tell them what to design: it gives them reliable carbon feedback on what they are designing.

emersus Concept interface for 10N: quantities by RICS element, 3D project model and live A1-A5, biogenic and B4 results.

Results based on the RICS methodology

A1-A5 and B4 emissions are calculated using the RICS methodology. Developed in the United Kingdom, it is widely applicable across the rest of the world, which made it the natural choice for a collective active on five continents. The calculation includes transport and construction site waste, and results are broken down by RICS building element categories.

Three indicators are displayed side by side, each answering a different question.

  • A1-A5 emissions measure the carbon emitted up to the building’s handover: material manufacturing, transport to site, and construction. This is the main indicator, the one that drives most trade-offs at concept stage. It is often used in the limits or targets set by international regulations and certifications (UK Net Zero Carbon Buildings Standard, RIBA, LETI, BREEAM).
  • Biogenic carbon is the carbon stored in plant-based materials, such as timber or certain insulation products. It is shown separately, so that the contribution of bio-based materials is visible without blurring the reading of the total.
  • Component replacements (B4) anticipate the emissions linked to replacing elements over the building’s life cycle, based on the service life of each product. An insulation with a lower upfront impact but needing more frequent replacement can thus turn out to be less attractive than it seems.

The breakdown of the carbon footprint per building element is shown in a summary chart: hotspots are clearly identified (structure, façade, roof, services…) to highlight where the efforts for reduction should focus.

The settings are designed for international use: RIBA work stages, building types (low-rise residential, flats, offices), default assumptions tailored to each typology, and an English-language interface.

Comparison of two concept-stage options and emissions broken down by RICS building element.

Day to day: an assessment in a few minutes

In practice, an LCA study takes place in three steps.

Describe the project. The architect creates a study by entering the building type and a few key dimensions: floor area, number of storeys, overall building shape. No detailed drawings or quantity take-offs needed: this information is available from the very first sketches.

Get a first assessment. From this data alone, Concept estimates the areas and quantities of each building component, assigns default macro-components to them and runs a first LCA calculation. The architect gets an initial result within minutes.

Test options. They can then swap one macro-component for another: a timber floor instead of concrete, a different façade, another insulation. With each change, they see the effect on the total and on each building element, and can compare several options before deciding.

Carbon thus becomes one design criterion among others, tabled from concept stage with the team and the client and tracked as a key metric rather than a figure recorded once the project is fixed.

What it changes for teams

For architects, carbon is no longer a constraint discovered late, nor the sole preserve of a specialist. They build it into their design process, with a tool that speaks their language: building systems, areas, options to compare.

For the carbon team, the macro-component library becomes a management lever. By defining the reference data once, the team ensures that all projects rely on validated assumptions, without having to check each study one by one. It can then update the library, and every team benefits.

For management and clients, assessments become comparable from one project to the next and from one studio to another. The figures presented rely on identified sources: they can be explained and defended, and used to steer building decarbonisation across the collective. It also becomes possible to use the carbon data from our concept-stage projects and to track the performance of our projects by sector, region, and so on.

« It was essential for us to control our emission factors while leaving our architects free to create, and to see the carbon impact of every idea. »

Etienne Daries

Carbon Lead – Sustainability Transformation

An approach that can be applied to other organisations

What was done for 10N can be done for others. In a custom version of emersus Concept, you can adapt:

  • the calculation method and the indicators displayed;
  • the macro-component library and emission factors;
  • building types and default assumptions.

A developer can thus compare the LCA of its schemes based on its own reference building systems. A group of practices or an engineering consultancy can share a single library across its teams, rather than adapting its practices to a standard LCA software.

Frequently asked questions

Contact us
What is early-stage LCA?
It is a life cycle assessment carried out from the earliest design stages, with little data. It provides an order of magnitude of the carbon footprint to compare options, rather than a final figure.
Can you use your own data?
Yes. In a custom version, the organisation defines its macro-component library and the emission factors they are made of. Its teams then work with this reference data.
Can users modify the reference data?
That is up to the organisation. At 10N, emission factors are defined by the carbon team, and architects choose freely from the macro-components in the library.

Make carbon a competitive advantage, not a constraint

Discover how emersus can transform your approach to LCA and save you valuable time. Our experts support you every step of the way for a successful onboarding.